Mao visto por Jung Chang y Jhon Halliday
Se acaba de publicar en español el libro de Jung Chang y Jhon Halliday Mao: La Historia Desconocida.
Los interesados en conocer a los autores de este polémico libro y la metodología que siguieron para escribirlo tienen a su disposición, en inglés, este webcast que recoge la entrevista y posterior coloquio que Chang y Halliday mantuvieron en la Universidad de Berkerley sobre su obra más reciente.
La parte más interesante del webcast, en mi opinión, es la que recoge las preguntas que, al terminar la entrevista, algunos de los asistentes al acto dirigieron a los autores del libro. Allí pude saber que la propia Chang ejerció como barefoot doctor (los “médicos” que Mao envió a las zonas rurales para ocuparse de la salud de los campesinos así llamados porque iban con sandalias y lo limitado de sus medios y, si hemos de creer a Chang, también de conocimientos) pese a no haber recibido ninguna formación médica.
Desgraciadamente, problemas informáticos me impiden seguir escribiendo este post, así que lo comentaré más adelante. Perdón por el descuido al redactarlo.
ADICIÓN Rafael Poch publica hoy en La Vanguardia una crítica del libro de Jung Chang y Jhon Halliday en la que dice que está falto de rigor histórico.
Los problemas del libro no se limitan a la China Continental, donde, como es obvio, no se ha publicado, sino que se extienden a Taiwan. El blog ESWN nos explica el porqué en esta entrada.
Ya para finalizar, una cuestión que va más allá de la crítica que del libro de Chang y Halliday hace Rafael Poch. ¿No es lógico que en las versiones on line de artículos como el de Poch aparezcan los enlances a las fuentes que se utilizan en ellos cuando éstas, como es el caso, están disponibles en internet y es más que probable que su autor las haya obtenido a través de esa vía?
Para el motivo por el que los periodistas no ponen sus fuentes, me remito al articulo que escribi hace algun tiempo…
Comment by Yun — May 14, 2006 @ 11:57 pm
please if some body know, let me know how I can write to Jung Chang.
Comment by Consuelo Wong — July 8, 2008 @ 12:24 am
please let me know how I can contact by e mail to Jung Chang or other media
Comment by Consuelo Wong — July 8, 2008 @ 12:26 am
Me parece un excelente libro, al igual que cisnes Salvajes y me encantaria cono cer más material de estos autores.
Comment by Carlos Daniel Silva — October 1, 2008 @ 9:30 pm
Tuve la oporunidad de escuhar Jung Chang y su esposo en HAy festival cartagena 2009. En la confrencia me decepciono la excesiva subjetividad en sus comentarios. A la pregunta sobre las fuente de sus argumentos, sencillament hacia refrencia a allegados y no a fuentes sustentadas. Demasiada arrogancia para una descripcion con documentacin. enoto Ira hcia la china de Mao, y no un soporte investigativo a la historia.
Comment by mario — February 2, 2009 @ 3:32 am
Pienso que estes es un excelente libro,puesto que nos habla de la otra cra de la moneda! lo estoy terminando de leer y para mi es impresionante la informacion que ofrece…realemnte creo que el libro puede aportarnos muchas cosas que para nosostros los que pertenecemos a esta generacion no sabiamos…les exorto que lo lean y que tengan una mente abirta…recuerden que las mentes con prejuicios son como los Bonsaiis, a los cuales se les cortan las raices para que no crezcan nunca…
Comment by Dr.daniel E.Rodriguez C,M.A. — August 7, 2010 @ 2:41 pm
This is perfect that people can get the home loans moreover, it opens up completely new opportunities.
Comment by FranklinBettie — December 21, 2010 @ 5:40 pm
Nike Air est coûteux que Air force nike pas cher
les chaussures athlétiques, comme raison de leur qualité et de confort. Si elles sont bien pris soin d’, Coach Pas Cher
ils durent beaucoup plus longtemps que les produits similaires.
Comment by Air force nike pas cher — October 12, 2011 @ 8:05 am
favorable lors de sa rencontre quelqu’un pour la première fois. La différence entre faire une grande impression ou une très mauvaise dépend souvent de votre capacité à lire et à comprendre une autre langue corps de Supra Shoes Pas Cher
personnes. Nous pouvons involontairement nuire communications avec nos messages non verbaux.
Comment by Supra Shoes Prix — October 12, 2011 @ 8:06 am
Urban guys and women now pick Moncler Down Jackets that once only belonged to an outdoor or polar dress as their prerequisite winter coat.
Comment by moncler outlet — October 13, 2011 @ 3:49 am
codes of official silence, such as true religion jeans outlet smoking. Especially in the United States, as they live, without worrying much
Comment by true religion jeans cheap — October 27, 2011 @ 7:14 am
In filing the claims, the railway workers allegedly paid between $800 and $1,200 to hire one of several disability doctors. north face clearanceThose doctors would then conduct unnecessary tests and concoct a medical issue that would allow the workers to go on disability, prosecutors said.
Comment by north face clearance — October 31, 2011 @ 6:11 am
welcome to: http://www.monclerjacketparkas.com/
Comment by moncler outlet — November 7, 2011 @ 2:56 am
thanks very much ,good information.That was exactly what I was looking for. You have done a wonderful job communicating your message. Keep up the good work.
Comment by wholesale fashion costume jewelry — November 8, 2011 @ 2:48 am
You are always giving so many new ideas and I hope it will continue in the future. That’s perfect, your words are really easy to perceive.
Comment by buy laptop battery — February 17, 2012 @ 1:00 pm
Extremely thin, even down to the white eyebrows long chest. is the old man’s hands are the most important with a pair of . just on a piece of cloth over chains. most people do not look simply note not to. the north face was followed for a long time, because the mask was blown up, see below the fabric chains.”Huh? it is sth” the north face for the first time to see this legendary tool, the “forbidden magic handcuffs?”Recorded in the book, banned magic handcuffs, magic forces can no longer be used in the body a little. powerful mages like an ordinary person like. However magic handcuffs are scarce precious-ban, the north face and this is the first time I saw it.
Comment by north face jackets clearance — February 18, 2012 @ 12:52 am
Personally, I think the authors actually fail to come up with enough evidence to support this argument. On the whole the book really seems to misrepresent the Soviet actions and motives
Comment by essay online — February 28, 2012 @ 2:38 pm
I love the Newport News catalog and web site. They not only have some of the best styles in women’s clothing, but they have a fantastic selection of pretty and inexpensive shoes. Since they’re not exclusively a shoe catalog, they do not have quite as large of an offering as other shoe sellers, but what they do have looks great and is quite affordable, with women’s shoes ranging from 10 -30 dollars per pair, and fantastic sales throughout the year
Comment by Cheap Supra Shoes — March 7, 2012 @ 6:56 am
C’est pourquoi j’aime cette couleur et quand nous parlons de Wolverine bottes, tout cet ensemble est livré
Comment by timberland — April 9, 2012 @ 1:02 am
Goose Relaterte produkter er også stadig mer populært, er Goose fett nå godt? Antas å være
Comment by Canada Goose Norge — April 9, 2012 @ 1:08 am
Hxing4 The Concord Mills Mall is top of the line when it comes to outlet malls. It’s located about an hour and a
half from Raleigh, in Concord, NC (about 45 mins. north of Charlotte, NC). Concord Mills is home to over 200
stores, including outlets and specialty stores, including a Bass Pro Shop. Entertainment includes Dave &
Busters, AMC Movie Theaters and a NASCAR SpeedPark.
Comment by christian louboutin discount — April 14, 2012 @ 3:28 am
other ten days and a half months, we can go back.” Lampson’s voice was low.Lampson very carefully, do not disclose the contents of any possible disclosure of identity.”Two years.” Nike Air Max 2012 Other backs on the north face, a black-robed man shook his head. ” In order to deal with this old guy, I’m the good brother died.
Nike Air Max 2011 “”As long as the good clearance, everything worth it.”
Comment by Nike Air Max 2011 — July 9, 2012 @ 9:27 am
We offer all kinds of Burberry Outlet for women, That is why Burberry Outlet have become the ultimate desire of every young girl nowadays.
Comment by Burberry Outlet — August 28, 2012 @ 3:06 am
I find it very friend of this site is encouraged. Also, I think I would like to thank you for your article. You to please upload something new, I can see the bookmark and definitely taste it.
Comment by outils diagnostic Auto — March 7, 2013 @ 6:39 am